News

Difference Between Dry Roller Compactor and Wet Granulator

Views: 1073 Author: Site Editor Publish Time: 2020-03-11 Origin: Site

Comparison between Dry Granulators and Wet Granulators

Dry granulators and wet granulators are two popular granulation technologies. Their main difference lies in whether a liquid binder is used—a fundamental distinction that leads to comprehensive variations in processes, equipment, applications, advantages, and disadvantages. Below is a detailed comparison:

I. Core Principle Comparison

Characteristic	Dry Granulator	Wet Granulator
Core Principle	Physical compression	Liquid bridging (binder-mediated adhesion)
Process	Powder → Roll-compressed dense sheets → Mechanical crushing into granules	Powder + Binder → Mixing & moistening → Extrusion/stirring into wet granules → Drying into dry granules
Binder Requirement	No liquid binder needed; relies on intermolecular forces and mechanical interlocking	Liquid binders (e.g., water, ethanol, starch paste) are mandatory

II. Process Flow & Equipment Comparison

Characteristic	Dry Granulator	Wet Granulator
Typical Process	1. Feeding 2. Roll compression 3. Crushing & granulation (No drying required)	1. Mixing raw materials & excipients 2. Adding binder & wet mixing 3. Granulation (oscillating/high-shear) 4. Drying (fluid bed/oven) 5. Secondary granulation (for uniformity)
Equipment Composition	Integrated single machine: Feeding system + Roll compression system + Crushing & granulation system	Equipment combination: Mixer + Granulator + Dryer + Secondary granulator
Space Requirement	Compact; completed by one machine	Distributed; requires multiple devices, occupying larger floor space

III. Advantages Comparison

Characteristic	Dry Granulator	Wet Granulator
Process Time	Extremely short (minutes-level), continuous production, high efficiency	Long (hours-level, especially drying time), batch production
Energy Consumption	Very low; no drying step, significant energy savings	High; drying is the main energy consumer
Suitable Materials	Moisture- or heat-sensitive materials (e.g., antibiotics, vitamins)	Common materials stable to moisture and heat
Safety & Environmental Friendliness	No solvent residue risk, no explosion risk, environmentally friendly	Risks of solvent safety, residue, and need for solvent recovery
Material Yield	High; minimal material loss	Relatively low; loss occurs during transfer, wall adhesion, and drying

IV. Disadvantages & Limitations Comparison

Characteristic	Dry Granulator	Wet Granulator
Equipment Cost	High initial investment; high maintenance cost	Relatively low initial investment
Process Development	More complex; extremely sensitive to raw material properties (fluidity, compressibility)	Relatively simple and mature; easier to master
Granule Properties	Granules are hard and dense (may affect tablet disintegration); irregular shape	Granules are looser and porous; cylindrical shape; better compressibility
Flexibility	Suitable for large-batch production of single formulas; complex cleaning for material changeovers	High flexibility; easy formula changeovers; suitable for multi-variety, small-batch production

V. Selection Guide: When to Choose Dry vs. Wet Granulation?

Choose a Dry Granulator if:

Your raw materials are moisture- or heat-sensitive (decompose in water or are unstable at high temperatures).
You need high production efficiency and low energy consumption for continuous manufacturing.
You pursue high material yield, especially for expensive raw materials (minimizing loss is critical).
You need to avoid any risk of solvent residue.
Your raw materials already have good compressibility and fluidity (no need for binders to improve properties).

Choose a Wet Granulator if:

Your raw materials are stable to moisture and heat (the most common scenario).
You need to handle multiple formulas with frequent product changeovers
Your budget is limited, and you want to reduce initial equipment investment.
You require granules with superior morphology and compressibility.
Your process team has more experience with wet granulation, and the technology is more mature in your workflow.

Summary Analogy

Dry granulation is like a "road roller": It compacts loose materials into dense sheets using high physical pressure, then crushes them to the required size. It is efficient and powerful but "picky" about material properties.
Wet granulation is like "kneading dough": It uses liquid (binder) to bond powder (like flour) into a cohesive mass, shapes it into "noodles" (wet granules), and finally dries them. It is versatile and flexible but involves more steps.

The final selection depends on a comprehensive assessment of product characteristics, production scale, quality requirements, and cost budgets. There is no absolute "better" option—only the most suitable one for your specific needs.

News

Difference Between Dry Roller Compactor and Wet Granulator

Get A Free PDF

QUICK LINK

main product

FIND US